| 1st Period |
| Columbus Goal - Rick Nash (30), from Mark Letestu and Vinny Prospal at 19:24. :36 Remaining. |
| 2nd Period |
| Columbus Goal - Cam Atkinson (6), unassisted at 4:15. 15:45 Remaining. |
| NY Islanders Goal - Milan Jurcina (3), from Frans Nielsen and Michael Grabner at 7:32. 12:28 Remaining. |
| Columbus Goal - R.J. Umberger (20), from Cam Atkinson and Derick Brassard at 11:12. 8:48 Remaining. |
| NY Islanders Goal - Kyle Okposo (24), from Milan Jurcina at 13:11. 6:49 Remaining. |
| Columbus Power-Play Goal - James Wisniewski (6), from Vinny Prospal and Jack Johnson at 18:48. 1:12 Remaining. |
| Columbus Power-Play Goal - Cam Atkinson (7), from Derek Dorsett and James Wisniewski at 19:31. :29 Remaining. |
| 3rd Period |
| Columbus Goal - Jack Johnson (12), from James Wisniewski and Derick Brassard at 4:41. 15:19 Remaining. |
| Columbus Goal - Vinny Prospal (16), from Nikita Nikitin at 11:03. 8:57 Remaining. |
| NY Islanders Goal - Michael Grabner (20), from Mark Streit and Dylan Reese at 16:27. 3:33 Remaining. |
