| 1st Period Summary |
| Time left | Team | Scoring Detail |
| No Scoring |
| Time | Team | Penalty Detail |
| 16:36 | Columbus | R.J. Umberger - 2 minutes for goaltender interference |
| |
| 2nd Period Summary |
| Time left | Team | Scoring Detail |
| 15:59 | Columbus | Columbus Power-Play Goal - Fredrik Modin (6), from Rick Nash and Fedor Tyutin at 4:01. |
| 1:54 | Columbus | Columbus Goal - Jason Chimera (7), from Mike Commodore at 18:06. |
| 0:10 | NY Islanders | NY Islanders Short-Handed Goal - Richard Park (5), from Andy Hilbert and Chris Campoli at 19:50. |
| Time | Team | Penalty Detail |
| 3:08 | NY Islanders | Mark Streit - 2 minutes for holding |
| 4:59 | Columbus | Rick Nash - 2 minutes for hooking |
| 18:21 | NY Islanders | Nate Thompson - 2 minutes for elbowing |
| |
| 3rd Period Summary |
| Time left | Team | Scoring Detail |
| 9:13 | Columbus | Columbus Goal - Andrew Murray (4), from Jakub Voracek and Kris Russell at 10:47. |
| Time | Team | Penalty Detail |
| 13:11 | Columbus | Marc Methot - 2 minutes for slashing |
| 16:17 | NY Islanders | Mark Streit - 2 minutes for cross-checking |
| 16:17 | Columbus | Jakub Voracek - 2 minutes for diving |
